To My Baby Brother: The Things You’ll Never Know, by Jessica


Also by Jessica on HA: “Copy Kids—The Immorality of Individuality” and “Christian Discipline, A Child’s Perspective.”

To my baby brother:

I know we don’t have the best relationship.

I know you think I’m ungrateful for the things my parents gave us. I know you think I ran away that day when I was 18.  I remember the day you told me I abandoned you.  I know you weren’t as mistreated and I am glad for that, because I’m your big sister.  I love you.

I can prove I love you in the things you’ll never know.

When you were little, you  liked to flush things down the toilet.  Dad was always snaking the drain in our little 2 bedroom trailer house.  It’s a  quirky kid thing.  One day, when you were 3 and I was 7 or 8, you flushed a match box car and clogged the drain.  Dad found out.  You ran to the bedroom screaming and locked the door.  You were 3.  You weighed 30 lbs soaking wet.  When dad got that door open, he sat down cross legged on the floor with you on his lap and started punching you.  I ran for him.  She made him stop.

I took a beating for you that night.

It was worth it and I would do it again.  This was the first time, it wasn’t the last.  I learned to take credit for your mistakes whenever I could when you were little.  I wish I had told him I flushed the car.

That day when I was 18, the day that made me leave, I cried all night.  I knew I had to leave.  I knew I wasn’t safe.  I knew being choked by my dad wasn’t normal.  I didn’t cry because I was worried for myself or that I was going to miss my parents.

I cried because I couldn’t take you or my older brother with me. 

I want you know though, I fought for you.  I spoke to your school about counseling for you.  I talked to social services. I spoke to an attorney.  I wasn’t trying to abandon you.  I thought about you every day and grieved when I was told their was nothing I could do.

You were just barely a teenager then and whether they will admit it or not, my parents learned something about smothering a teenager.  It backfires. You, little brother, were in public school after kindergarten and received a full education.  Be grateful for that, you’ll never know how valuable that is.  You were able to take drivers ed.  I heard one year that you were out celebrating halloween with your friends and I cried that day because I realized they were giving you freedom.  You were allowed to date.  You were given a car and they assisted you with college.

I am glad that they gave you a better a life. 

You were however, still abused.  I can’t say that enough and you need to hear it.  Dad was beating you too.  I remember your middle of the night cries.

So little brother, when we discuss these painful things, I need you to try to remember how things were.  I payed a price in love to try to make your life a little better.  I need to you to try to remember and see things from a little different perspective.  I don’t want you to stop loving mom and dad.  You guys have a good relationship.  I just want you to know that I fought for you.

I did not just run away. I didn’t abandon you.

6 thoughts on “To My Baby Brother: The Things You’ll Never Know, by Jessica

  1. Heidi Underhill November 27, 2013 / 2:08 pm

    I hope your brother can read and understand this some day. I am so sorry that you had to go through this. No child deserves to be beat.


  2. N℮üґ☼N☮☂℮ṧ November 27, 2013 / 3:13 pm

    My heart aches for you, Jessica. 😦
    Jessica, I hope you found healing in writing this. I also hope your brother will come to realize what an incredibly courageous, loving and compassionate person you are.


  3. lmanningok December 4, 2013 / 10:17 am

    Where are the authorities in all this? We live in a country whose citizens are protected by the Constitution. The Bible is NOT the law of America; the Constitution is, and it protects all citizens from abuse, even children whose parents abuse them. Christian Patriarchy homeschooling is as much a cult as the FLDS and should be abolished. Keep up the posts, and maybe someday enough people will get mad enough to help you children.


  4. elizabeth watkins December 9, 2013 / 5:30 pm

    i know exactly how you feel. as the oldest of seven children who were forcibly homeschooled, physically and emotionally abused every day of our lives – i too cried when i ran away. for the ones i left behind. i have been fortunate enough to be able to help some of the younger ones get away and get lives of their own. Still, everyday I think of the two still left there, trapped in a hell of our mother’s creation. your story brought tears to my eyes. i feel your pain.


  5. Eleanor Skelton January 12, 2015 / 9:01 am

    I took a couple of beatings for my siblings as well. Wow…this really reasonates.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s